Popcorn On Couch presents another edition of Cinema Clash where I invite someone to debate two movies which are similar or connected in some sort of way and we battle it out, pitching why we thought our choice of movie was better. In this edition of Cinema Clash we have Prisoners Vs Gone Baby Gone; both movies focus on detectives trying to find abducted children. I have invited Jakob Lewis Barnes from JumpCut UK who will be pitching for Prisoners in this thrilling showdown.
Let the battle begin!
Battle One: Intro

If you ask me about Denis Villeneuve today, I could discuss his work for hours, but back in 2013 as I was heading into the cinema to see Prisoners, I had no idea what to expect. I left the cinema that night absolutely stunned, and quite frankly, haunted by what I had watched. Villeneuve, as we’ve seen with Sicario too, is a modern day master of suspense and intensity, and Prisoners is the perfect example of an edge-of-your-seat mystery thriller. Whilst I enjoyed Gone Baby Gone, the film just didn’t have that lasting effect that Prisoners did, and still does today.
– Jakob Lewis Barnes

Prisoners is a good movie, had a great cast, excellent story and I liked it, but Gone Baby Gone really stuck with me and had my full attention. I was completely captivated, engaged and engrossed in Gone Baby Gone’s unpredictable story. Gone Baby Gone may not have that dark, disturbing atmosphere like Prisoners; however it lingered on my mind for days as it touches on moral issues that really make you think and question character’s decision. It’s been a while since I’ve watched Gone Baby Gone but honestly I still think about the decision Casey Affleck’s character had to make at the end. This film is an unforgettable, amazing, shocking, surprising and thought-provoking Mystery Thriller.
– Olatide Renee
Battle Two: Story

The story of Gone Baby Gone is decent enough, but is guilty of being a little bit predictable. The complete opposite can be said for Prisoners; I remember watching it for the first time and thinking “what the hell is going on here!?” It’s a beautifully dark and twisted mystery movie, a brilliant example of the good old “whodunit”, and for all its sinister elements of child abduction, it is a shockingly realistic tale. If you’ve never seen Prisoners before, you’re in for a real treat as you watch the disturbing secrets unfold, and even if – like me – you’ve seen it a few times, the suspense still holds up, and you notice more and more each time.
– Jakob

Prisoners is a good mystery which has a lasting effect but just makes viewers wonder who done it, Gone Baby Gone is similar but is more as it takes it up a notch. Not only does it make you wonder who done it, it also has a complex story with a deeper meaning which touches on morals, decisions and conscience. The story really is unpredictable; you think it’s this person but then the story throws another twist at you. Similar to prisoners Gone Baby Gone focuses on two private investigators and two detectives trying to find a missing child. Unlike Prisoners the abducted child doesn’t have a good upbringing which makes her own family members suspects making the mystery harder to solve. I’ll say Gone baby Gone definitely has more twists, the story is built up well and as the mystery unfolds it becomes more shocking and surprising.
– Olatide
Battle Three: Cast

Full disclaimer here, I’m a massive fan of Jake Gyllenhaal and everything he does, but believe me – there’s no bias here when I say that the guy is fantastic in Prisoners. Gyllenhaal works perfectly as the troubled detective hunting down the abducted children, and this could arguably be right up there as one of his best performances. Alongside him, we have Hugh Jackman, of whom I’m not usually a big fan, but this a real emotional powerhouse performance from Mr Wolverine. Rounding out the stellar ensemble cast is Paul Dano. This was the first role I saw the young man in, and I was blown away (and terrified) by how convincing he was as the local creepy kid. I have to say though, Amy Ryan was superb in Gone Baby Gone, and very deserving of her Oscar nomination for the performance.
– Jakob

All the performances in Prisoners were great from Gyllenhaal, Jackman and Dano. The same thing can be said for the performances in Gone Baby Gone as everyone delivered a brilliant and breath-taking performance which made Gone Baby Gone a better film. Casey Affleck shines as the street smart private investigator he performs with style and charisma, he’s portrayal of Patrick was terrific and we can really see how the case consumes him. Amy Ryan delivers an excellent performance as Helene McCready which she received a well-deserved Oscar nomination for; she did a great job of playing a repulsive, irresponsible and naïve mother. Gone Baby Gone had a fantastic ensemble cast consisting of Morgan Freeman, Michelle Monaghan & Ed Harris whom gave mesmerizing performances. Everyone was just magnificent in this film even Edi Gathegi as drug Lord Cheese, he gave a brilliant performance despite his extremely short screen time.
– Olatide
Battle Four: Direction

As I mentioned before, Denis Villeneueve has quickly established himself as one of the top directors working today and has really nailed the dark, tense tone to his films. As a big fan of the dark and macabre, Villeneuve is right up my street, and is really an inspiration to my own filmmaking ventures. He juxtaposes close-up shots and lingering, long distance shots to really stir the emotions, build suspense, and keep us guessing as to what’s coming next. The pacing here, which switches between patient brooding and high intensity, is perfectly complimented by the score of Johann Johannson (with whom he also worked on Sicario), to give Prisoners that haunting quality which sees it almost verge on being a horror-of-sorts.
– Jakob

Gone Baby Gone is Ben Affleck’s first feature film, and in this film he showed not only is he talented in front of the camera but also behind. Affleck has then go on to direct Argo and The Town which have both been highly praised by critics, showing he is a force to be reckoned with. In Gone Baby Gone Affleck sets a realistic tone of working-class Boston, he captures a real and disturbing hometown which can suck the goodness out of you. Affleck creates a dense, dark and mysterious tone from the onset giving you that chilling feeling. He backs this up with superb storytelling and does a great job of establishing character’s personalities, views and morals.
– Olatide
Final Battle
I was very impressed with Gone Baby Gone – I especially loved the way the filming style made me feel almost part of the community we see on screen – but it just doesn’t come close to Prisoners for me. I regard that first viewing of Prisoners as one of the best cinema experiences I’ve ever had, and ‘Prisoners’ sits at number 27 in my top 50 films of all time, which is high praise indeed, believe me. As far as tense mystery-thrillers go, there are very few films which can top the feeling Prisoners will imprint on you.
– Jakob
There are many crime thrillers out there, many of them similar to Gone Baby Gone in terms of story. But what makes Gone Baby Gone stand out is that lasting effect it has on you and how it causes you to debate the decisions made. Gone Baby Gone is an interesting, engaging and gripping film and I definitely prefer it to prisoners and I still believe Prisoners is a good film. But for me Gone Baby Gone was just near perfect; the cast was great, the acting was outstanding, the story was unpredictable and the direction was strong. Not many films have impacted me the way Gone Baby Gone has.
– Olatide
Now you guys have the opportunity to vote, which movie was better? Use the poll below and leave your opinions in the comment section.
Check out @jumpcutjakob & @popcornoncouch Cinema clash here: https://t.co/maj1GAugDW Vote Which Movie is better ?
— Popcorn On Couch (@popcornoncouch) 9 August 2016
I’ll like to thank Jakob Lewis Barnes for collaborating with me on this epic Cinema Clash, be sure to visit JumpCut UK for the latest movie news, trailers, reviews & more!
If you are interested in collaborating with me for future Cinema Clash, contact me via the contact page.