Popcorn On Couch is proud to present another edition of Mixed Reviews Monday, where we get your opinions and ratings on a movie with very different reviews. I asked you to vote between Life, Ghost In The Shell, Power Rangers and Beauty And The Beast for our tenth Mixed Reviews Monday.
Which movie would you like to discuss for our 10th #MixedReviewsMonday ?
— Popcorn On Couch (@popcornoncouch) 3 April 2017
It was close but Ghost In The Shell came out on top!
Ghost In The shell a live action remake of a beloved anime film of the same name from 1995. Ever since its announcement Ghost In The Shell has been receiving a lot of heat due to its whitewashing, its casting of Scarlett Johansson as the lead was met with anger from many people. The only thing that could save Ghost In The Shell were good reviews, however Ghost In The Shell is another remake which has received mixed reviews.
Is Ghost In The Shell an entertaining and successful live action remake? Or just another failed remake which doesn’t live up to the original?
Scroll down to see the different opinions we have received from our wonderful twitter followers.
The “This is a cool Sci-fi with a good story” Reviews
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan Appealing Visuals, Great Origins Story and shades of Shutter Island – best sci-fi seen since Arrival, best Scarlett film in way too long 4/5
— Realweegiemidge Blog (@realweegiemidge) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch Was just pretty damn cool with such a well-realised world and ideas, I appreciated latter plot developments too. 4/5.
— Embarr (@EmbarrFilms) 7 April 2017
The “This is a disappointing remake without heart” Reviews
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @NextBestPicture @__Nathan 2/5
— Alistair Ryder (@YesitsAlistair) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan *cough*1.5/5*cough*
— Lee Brady (@BigPicReviews) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch #MixedReviewsMonday pic.twitter.com/KIsLLD7vBP
— 🍿 (@__Nathan) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan Beautiful on the outside, rotten on the inside. Ghost in the Shell a clear example of taking a property and drowning it in nothing but style
— Express Film (@ExpressFilm_) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan Looks amazing but the script is clunky and the pace too languid. 2/5
— Darren Gaskell (@darren_gaskell) 8 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @CrisMovieCorner @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan I am always here for brightly-colored sci-fi and badass Johansson, but great look can’t save it from so many tone-deaf decisions. 2.5/5
— Dancin Dan on Film (@dancindanonfilm) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan 2 out of 5. An hour after seeing it I had trouble remembering anything of note
— Niall McArdle (@ragingfluff) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan Not a film to be hated; more a shrug of the shoulders. All shell, no Ghost. 2/5
— Darth Cause (@violet_cause) 7 April 2017
The “This is an alright & visually stunning film which has problems with its story” Reviews
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @__Nathan 3/5
— Matt Neglia (@NextBestPicture) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan Not a bad film. Visually awesome and had some good concepts, but the lack of story was a problem. The action was cool though 3/5
— Chelsea Baines (@ChelseaBaines) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch Design & cinematography are great. The over familiar narrative is told adequately but the whitewashing overshadows. 3/5.
— HCMovieReviews (@HCMovieReviews) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan It was alright. The special effects and music were great and some of the characters were good, but the movie was never quite special.
— Movie Vet (@Movie_Vet) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan 3 Stars. A visually stunning film that unfortunately lacks in the story department. So much potential, such lacklustre execution.
— Adam Farrand (@ALFarrand) 7 April 2017
@popcornoncouch @BigPicReviews @EmbarrFilms @AngusMcGregor11 @YesitsAlistair @NextBestPicture @__Nathan #GhostInTheShell suffers a little for telling too big a story, leading to a few jumps in logic but still a welcome return to cyberpunk! 3/5
— Adam Tyler (@adam_tyler89) 7 April 2017
We received various reviews on Ghost In The Shell, majority were negative and thought the remake lacked heart. Most of our followers agreed that the film was visually stunning and had fantastic cinematography. However many people said there were a lot of problems with the story while some enjoyed the movie and liked the story.
We’ll like to thank all our wonderful followers for posting their opinions for Mixed Reviews Monday. If you would like to see your opinion for the next Mixed Reviews Monday follow us on twitter @popcornoncouch and subscribe to our newsletter to get updated on reviews, blog posts and Mixed Reviews Monday.